John Roberts may be leading the Senate impeachment trial
In a small Capitol Hill office after President Donald Trump had been impeached and official Washington bolted town for the holidays, bague argent jaunie a three person team gathered to dig through musty old law books and congressional records. president. In just a few weeks, they bague argent portugal would have to advise Chief Justice John Roberts on how to run that trial and address a slew of arcane procedural questions that few if any had ever been asked. Their answers, they knew, could influence how the historic bague argent rondelle event unfolded.
They also looked at 17 other impeachment cases involving judges and other government officials dating to the John Adams administration. They made notes and downloaded all manner of material onto the laptops and internal systems they would be able to bring to the Senate floor bague argent pierre de lune bleu and access at a moment’s notice.
« They’re up to their eyeballs in preparations, » said Alan Frumin, a former Senate parliamentarian and one of MacDonough’s mentors.
In a few days, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is expected to send two articles of impeachment against Trump to the Senate, kicking off a trial. While Roberts is tasked with overseeing the proceedings from the Senate’s most prominent bague argent femme rond chair, it will be MacDonough hovering, omnipresent but essentially unseen, in the corner of the frame, offering guidance the entire time.
« America is about to get to know Elizabeth bague argent ying et yang MacDonough, » Moira Whelan, bague argent avec pierres a Democratic strategist and former Obama era State Department senior official, recently posted on Twitter.
MacDonough, 53, will bring to her assignment more than 20 years of Capitol Hill experience as a non partisan career government employee, going all the way back to her days in the Senate Library. history. Along the way, MacDonough has played pivotal roles helping senators navigate vicious debates over taxes, government shutdowns and health care. She helped the upper chamber work through the controversial decision monture de bague argent to remove the filibuster as a weapon to block judicial nominations.
One of MacDonough’s most important assignments came in the wake of the Sept. Capitol ever needed to be evacuated and the government relocated.
Her job has many bosses. All 100 senators look to the parliamentarian’s office for advice as they draft one more bague diamant legislation. Senate committees find out from MacDonough’s team which bills are headed their way. On the floor, she’s the one who provides guidance to the presiding officer whenever there’s a question or debate about precedent or procedure.
« I’ve been here with many, many parliamentarians. All were good. But she’s the best, » said Vermont Democratic Sen. Patrick Leahy, the longest active serving senator.
« She’s tough, » added Texas GOP Sen. John Cornyn, the former majority whip. « She calls them straight down bague diamant tumblr the middle. »
For the Trump trial, MacDonough’s three person office will get the added responsibility of serving as netoyer bague argent the main liaison for Roberts, who along with a select group of aides must make the short commute into a building that they typically only visit on ceremonial occasions.
Her team will be tasked with delivering to Roberts grosse bague argent moderne the daily program that he’ll use to guide the proceedings. She will also be the one helping Roberts keep track of the clock as he calls on the people with assigned speaking roles Trump’s White House and personal attorneys, Senate leaders and the House impeachment managers who will present the case for the Democrats. It’s a critical task for a chamber that operates on a series of careful agreements dictating time management.
At times, MacDonough’s bague argent perle noire deputy, Leigh Hildebrand, will also occupy the parliamentarian’s chair. Hildebrand, a Senate staffer entering her 15th year, is also a well known face around Capitol Hill.
Perhaps most importantly, though, MacDonough will be the one who must give the chief justice instant advice should he need to make any snap rulings or decisions that could influence the trajectory of the trial.
Unforeseen events also loom. While the members are supposed to sit silently during large portions of the trial, they do have the right to raise objections, pose questions and hold press conferences right outside reparation bague diamant the ornate chamber doors. The whole bague argent saphir et zirconium world will be watching, too, including one person Trump with more than 70 million Twitter followers and little restraint on raining down invective on previously unknown figures.
MacDonough is no stranger to Capitol Hill. Senators feted the moment she made history as the first woman to get bague argent message the job. Freshmen preparing for their inaugural turn chairing the Senate have described her as a lifeline to navigating arcane legislative questions.
Yet given the inherent political nature of her job, MacDonough also faced some criticism. Conservatives ripped MacDonough, for example, over a 2017 procedural ruling that hindered the Senate GOP’s bague diamant 0 15 ct attempts to dismantle the Affordable Care Act.
She’s taken the criticism in stride. During a commencement speech in 2018 at her alma mater, the Vermont Law School, MacDonough weaved together stories about some of those tense showdowns with more light hearted moments, bague diamant or jaune et blanc such as a quip about Sen. Marco Rubio’s awkward reach to grab a sip of water during a nationally televised speech.
« Taking the long view is a part of what I do every day as I represent the interest of my unseen client, the institution of bague argent canyon the Senate itself, » MacDonough said. « While serving its 100 members on a day to day basis, I still represent the Senate. No matter who is in my office asking for assistance, I represent the Senate with its traditions of unfettered debate, protection of minority rights and equal power among the states. »
Of course, senators don’t have to listen to her either. Reid and the Democrats, for example, overruled MacDonough in 2013 when they invoked the « nuclear option » to end the requirement that 60 votes were needed to confirm executive branch nominations and non Supreme Court federal judicial appointments. She faced the same predicament in 2017 when McConnell changed the Senate rules so future Justice Neil Gorsuch could get confirmed to the Supreme Court without having to find the votes needed to overcome a filibuster.
« It was a stinging defeat that I tried not to take personally, » MacDonough recalled in her speech to the graduating students. « The one thing I can tell you about situations like this. It will never feel good, or rewarding enough, to bague argent chevron say, ‘I told you so,’ when people finally understand the point of which you are trying to convince them. »
MacDonough and, in turn, Roberts may end up breaking new ground during the Trump impeachment trial. Chief justices have only presided over two Senate trials involving presidents, and neither left much in the way of precedent. Back in 1868, the parliamentarian’s role didn’t even exist when Chief Justice Salmon Chase opted for a highly assertive role during the trial of President Andrew Johnson, which ended in his acquittal.
More than a century later, bague argent claddagh femme the Senate parliamentarian’s office built a dossier as it geared up for a Nixon trial that then Chief Justice Warren Burger would have overseen. While the Senate never got that case, the parliamentarian at the time, Floyd Riddick, explained in an interview with the Senate historian that his research backed up the notion that the parliamentarian would be essential for any future chief justice who presides over another impeachment trial.
« I would assume that the chief justice, whether he always followed the advice of the parliamentarian or not, would at least want him there to give him the benefit of what the practices of the Senate had been, and then he would have the bague diamant forme same right that all presiding officers have to ignore the advice of the parliamentarian and rule as he bague argent topaz wanted, » Riddick said.
At Clinton’s 1999 trial, Chief Justice William Rehnquist tried to maintain a hands off approach.
He later told TV interviewer Charlie Rose that he « did nothing in particular and I did it very well. » But Rehnquist, who had written his own book in part about the Andrew Johnson impeachment trial, did issue several controversial rulings, including one instance in which he ignored the advice of the parliamentarian to rule that the 100 senators shouldn’t be referred to as « jurors. »
Frumin, the parliamentarian at the time, recalled that he hadn’t been expecting the issue to come up, forcing him to scramble in real time to find bague argent javel the right materials while still paying attention to the debate. But Rehnquist, as was his right, made his own decision…